I have read with interest your thoughtful replies and thoughts on Adam and the “Freddie speech.” And appreciate seeing your viewpoints. There are some points which, I think, may not have considered.
1. There is an old theater saying goes, “remember, in your audience each night will be someone for whom this will be their first show, and someone for whom this will be their last.” I interpret this to mean, basically, don’t let the quality of your show deteriorate.” Adam may be considering those who have never seen the show, and continue the speech with them in mind.
2. We can only guess and extrapolate as to what input or feedback Brian and Roger have as to the speech and its content and impact.
3. Adam may receive feedback from friends, audience members, fans, that they appreciated the speech, and thought it enhanced the show.
4. For most people, I would guess that they will only see the speech one time. For us diehard fans, who have seen it many many times both at shows and on videos, the perspective may be altered by repetition.
5. Unless the speech is orchestrated by Brian and Roger, I think it is up to Adam to decide whether he wants to make the speech. If it is under Adam’s control, there has to be a reason he continues with the speech.
6. It is possible that the reviewers would concentrate on Freddie’s absence regardless of Adam’s speech.
Not trying to change anyone's viewpoint or stir anything up. For me it is a moot point, as I have my opinion of Adam fully formed and am just happy to see him up there singing. The presence or absence of the speech doesn’t really impact my enjoyment.